Objective:
We assessed how much each rope bag could carry, focusing on whether it could securely accommodate a standard climbing rope (up to 70 meters), along with supplementary climbing gear such as harnesses, climbing shoes, and quickdraws. Capacity is crucial as climbers need a reliable space to transport all essentials without compromising on organization.

Method:
We tested each bag by packing it with a climbing rope, two pairs of climbing shoes, a harness, and additional items like chalk bags. We noted the ease of fitting these items and evaluated whether the bag retained its shape without overstretching or damaging seams.

Outcome:
The North Face Duffel Black White excelled with its cavernous capacity, earning a 10/10. The Petzl Kliff Rope Pack also impressed with its ability to accommodate gear efficiently (9/10). Bags like the Metolius Dirt Bag II Rope struggled slightly to fit extra items alongside the rope.

Objective:
The goal was to evaluate the robustness of each bag, focusing on resistance to wear and tear from abrasive surfaces, exposure to dirt, and hauling under tough conditions. Climbers rely on the longevity of their gear, especially when exposed to sharp rocks, rough terrains, or varying weather conditions.

Method:
We dragged each bag across rocky surfaces, exposed it to dirt and mud, and repeatedly packed and unpacked it. We examined stitching, fabric integrity, and closures after the tests.

Outcome:
The Black Diamond Equipment Stonehauler Duffel received top marks (10/10) for its ultra-durable material and reinforced stitching. The Dr Dry Arbormax Rope Bag and North Face Duffel Black White also showcased excellent durability. In contrast, the Dmm Classic Rope Bag showed minor signs of wear after extended testing.

Objective:
We wanted to measure the products’ comfort during transport, specifically focusing on padded straps, weight distribution, and ergonomic design. Since climbing often involves hiking to remote crags, comfort during transportation is critical.

Method:
We filled each bag to its maximum capacity and carried it over a 2-mile hike with uneven terrain. Testers noted the feel of the straps, the pressure on their shoulders, and whether the weight was evenly distributed.

Outcome:
The Dmm Classic Rope Bag scored a 9/10 for its comfortable padded straps and great weight distribution. The Dr Dry Arbormax Rope Bag was also praised for its blend of ergonomic design and adjustability. Meanwhile, the Metolius Dirt Bag II Rope lagged behind due to thinner straps that became uncomfortable over time.

Objective:
We explored how easily users could pack and retrieve their gear. Quick and straightforward access is essential, especially during time-sensitive setups at climbing spots or cleaning up post-climb.

Method:
Testers evaluated the bags based on zipper placement, drawstring efficiency, and the presence of organizational features like compartments and rope tarp integration. The time taken to pack and unpack gear was recorded for comparison.

Outcome:
The Black Diamond Equipment Stonehauler Duffel earned the highest marks (9/10), thanks to its large opening and internal organization. The Petzl Kliff Rope Pack also performed well, aided by its easy-to-use drawstring closure. The Dmm Classic Rope Bag, however, was less user-friendly due to its narrower opening.

Objective:
The focus was on how easy it was to transport each rope bag between different locations. Portability was assessed based on the bag’s weight, compactness when empty, and overall practicality when carried.

Method:
We analyzed the bag designs, focusing on how well they could be stored or transported when not in use. Testers also assessed how comfortably the bags carried when fully loaded during urban transit or on trails.

Outcome:
The Petzl Kliff Rope Pack (8/10) and Dr Dry Arbormax Rope Bag (7/10) stood out for their compact designs and lightweight nature. In contrast, the North Face Duffel Black White, while having exceptional capacity, was bulkier and less convenient for tight storage spaces.